Best for: Backpacker travellers and people new to tramping.
Avoid if: You want top performance in a tramping specific pack. (You intend solely on a tramping pack)
Reviewer Rating: 4⭐️
Overall score: –/100
MODEL
PRICE
WEIGHT
TERRAIN
SCORE
Osprey Talon 44L
$350 NZD
1.3kg
Tramping
-/100
Cactus Foray 75L
$1,000 NZD
3kg
Multi day tramping
60/100
Macpac Genesis 85L
$500 NZD
3.4 kg
Travel, Tramping, backpacking.
-/100
Tested by: NZ hiking guide
Key: 1=Very poor 2=Poor 3= Decent 4= Great 5 = Best in category
1=20 points 5=100 points toward overall rating
Ideal user: Travelling backpackers or first time overnight trampers. The 85L allows for lots of space (as you may not have expensive compact gear yet). You will learn to cut weight the hard way but the pack is versatile. Also with the attached day pack makes it great for travel.
Ideal terrain: NZ national parks, tracks, DOC tracks, off trail, Overseas travel.
You are wanting a tramping specific pack. firstly the size is bigger than ideal. with modern gear you should easily be able to use a 65L pack for big multi day tramps. Secondly the travel features (like the duffel bag conversion material) are extra baggage to lug around, you can go lighter. In saying that this pack still works well just not as well as a tramping specific pack.
Terrain tested: Off trail, on trail, guiding, river crossing, Travel.
Weather tested: Rain, coastal, alpine, hot weather.
Distance or time worn: Minimum 50 days 250km
Verdict:
This was my first pack and I don’t regret the purchase. It is super versatile and can be used on so many occasions weather that be travel, Long multi day tramps or Glamps. The day pack I almost never use with the big pack but it’s a great bonus. Also when travelling some people spot the day pack and tag it as well but even then they don’t make me pay for extra check in. As a tramping pack it is pretty heavy and lacks the fun features like hip belt pockets and deep water bottle pockets but setting that aside it has a bunch of access zippers to the main pack and is surprisingly comfortable. It has a bottom zipper and segment, front zipper and top “zip/rolltop” making it luxury for packing and unpacking. the downside for travellers is if you leave the bag at the hostel you best bring a bunch of padlocks as there is at least 3 zips you will need to protect your main bag.
Category: Packs
Tested by: Jack
Location(s) tested: Fiordland, Queenstown area, tested in guided trips as well as personal.
Duration of use: 4.5 guiding seasons on and off as well as personal use, Southeast Asia travel
Macpac is one of New Zealand’s most popular outdoor brands and over the past 5 years they have some packs that have stayed very similar standing the test of time while other ones with more features are coming on the shelves. This pack has been around for a while while some features are being added every now and then.
A Pack very much targeting Backpacker travellers.
Weight: 3.4KG – 7.4Lbs (with day pack 490g)
Price (NZD): $500
Intended use: Backpacking, Tramping, Travel.
Conditions tested in: multi day, rain, wind, remote, off trail, travel.
how the gear actually performed on real trips.
Comfort: Good. Acknowledging it’s hard to be comfortable carrying around 85L worth of kit its a pretty solid option. The reason I rate this below 4/5 is because I think there are more comfortable options out there. Also every time they update this it seems to keep the weight closer to your back (great) and less on your shoulders.
3.5/5
Durability: I have rated this pretty high but not a perfect 5 as the AzTec material seems very consistently strong the only downside is the features and buckles can break. NOTE Macpac in my experience backs their product and will fix buckles and zips if the pack is new. worst case they charge you a small amount.
4/5
Weather resistance: Really solid. AzTec material holds up really well in saturated conditions. Always take a pack liner or dry bags but this will hold up.
4.5/5
Packability / weight: Packability would score a 4.5/5 while weight is 3/5. Having front access as well as a hood, it packs well, the reason it doesn’t score 5 is because it doesn’t have hip belt pockets and the water bottle slip sits short.
4/5
Anything that stood out (good or bad): The Pack is a really strong option and designed exactly for backpackers, the only thing that may be able to be improved for backpackers is to make it more easily lockable (if storing it in a dodgy hostel there’s a lot of pockets to lock). Don’t know any current packs designed for this kind of thing. really well thought out.
Would you personally use this gear again? Yes
It is a pack I may use if I was travelling and needed a check in bag. Keeps your trip flexible to tramping while away (note when travelling I have had issues with the daypack on the outside they may tag it but haven’t charged me $$). I have a big inventory of packs so would unlikely be my first option on a tramp.